子公司“自下而上”的制衡:实现路径、弱化因素与作用边界
作者:
作者单位:

作者简介:

通讯作者:

中图分类号:

F276;F832.51

基金项目:

国家自然科学基金项目"'舍利取义'还是'为名所累'?中国情境下高管声誉的双重治理效应及优化路径研究"(71872103);国家自然科学基金项目"金字塔结构下母子公司'双向治理'形成机理与协同效应研究"(71872101);山东省社会科学规划重点项目"习近平总书记关于全面深化国有企业改革思想及其实践影响研究"(17BZLJ09)


Research on the “Bottom-up” balanced effect of subsidiaries:Realization path, weakening factors and function boundary
Author:
Affiliation:

Fund Project:

  • 摘要
  • |
  • 图/表
  • |
  • 访问统计
  • |
  • 参考文献
  • |
  • 相似文献
  • |
  • 引证文献
  • |
  • 资源附件
  • |
  • 文章评论
    摘要:

    如何有效约束大股东掏空行为是公司治理学术界与实践界共同关注的焦点问题。传统的委托代理框架遵循母子公司"自上而下"的单向治理逻辑,忽视了子公司的自主性及其"自下而上"的制衡能力,难以从根本上解决子公司及其中小股东利益保护问题。尽管单向治理范式已经受到学者的质疑,但子公司通过何种方式对母公司产生制衡亟需进一步探索。文章基于前景理论的核心观点,运用2012—2017年中国上市子公司的平衡面板数据,采用多元回归方法验证了子公司管理者异质性对大股东掏空行为的影响,阐释了子公司"自下而上"制衡作用的实现路径、弱化因素及其作用边界。研究结果表明:上市子公司拥有能力较强的管理团队能够显著抑制大股东掏空行为。一方面,能力较强的管理者可以为大股东带来更多的控制权共享收益,限制了其控制权私有收益的获取,另一方面,也能够更加有效地识别与监督大股东的掏空行为,进而起到对大股东"自下而上"的制衡作用。作为具有双重效应的情境变量,CEO声誉及CEO与母公司关联度在中国情境下的负面效应更为凸显,二者均会弱化管理者能力对大股东掏空行为的制衡作用,即在子公司CEO声誉水平较高、子公司CEO与母公司关联度较强的情境下,子公司管理者能力对大股东掏空行为的抑制作用较弱。在拓展性研究中,根据子公司股权集中度与股权制衡度进行分组,对不同股权结构下子公司管理者能力的制衡作用进行比较。结果发现,在低股权集中度与高股权制衡度的样本中,子公司管理者能力对大股东掏空行为的抑制效应显著,而在高股权集中度与低股权制衡度的样本中,即在大股东拥有较多的控制权,其他股东对大股东的制衡作用较弱的情况下,子公司管理者能力对大股东掏空行为的抑制作用难以显现,进一步揭示了子公司管理者能力的作用边界。经过工具变量法、分组回归、替换变量等稳健性检验与内生性处理之后,原结论依旧成立。研究结论补充和丰富了管理者能力在公司治理领域的研究,突破了传统"自上而下"单向治理理论的观点,验证了子公司"自下而上"制衡机制的可行性,为解决以大股东机会主义为特征的第二类代理问题提供了新的思路与经验证据。

    Abstract:

    How to restrain the tunneling behavior of major shareholders is a focal issue of both academic and practical concerns in corporate governance. The traditional principal-agent framework follows the one-way governance logic of "top-down" parent-subsidiary, ignoring the autonomy of subsidiaries and their "bottom-up" checks and balances, which makes it difficult to solve the problem of protecting the interests of subsidiaries and their minority shareholders fundamentally. Although the one-way governance paradigm has been questioned by scholars, the ways through which subsidiaries can provide checks and balances to the parent company need to be further explored. Based on the viewpoint of prospect theory, this paper uses balanced panel data of Chinese listed subsidiaries from 2012 to 2017, and uses multiple regression method to verify the influence of the heterogeneity of subsidiary executives on tunneling, and explains the realization path, weakening factors and the boundary of the "bottom-up" checks and balances of subsidiaries. The results show that subsidiary executives with strong ability can restrain tunneling significantly. On the one hand, executives with strong ability can bring more shared benefits to the major shareholders, limiting their access to private benefits of control rights. On the other hand, they can identify and supervise tunneling effectively, and then play a "bottom-up" check and balance role for the major shareholders. As situational variables with dual effects, the negative effects of CEO reputation and the CEO connectedness with parent company are more prominent in China, and both of them will weaken the check and balance of managerial ability on tunneling, that is, under the situation that the reputation level of subsidiary CEO is high and the CEO connectedness with parent company is strong, the inhibition effect of subsidiary managerial ability on tunneling is weak. In the expanded research, this paper compares the governance effects of managerial ability under different situational factors by grouping equity concentration and equity balance. The results show that in the samples with low equity concentration and high equity balance, the inhibition effect of subsidiary managerial ability on tunneling is significant, while in the samples with high equity concentration and low equity balance, that is, when major shareholders have more control rights and other shareholders have weak checks and balances on major shareholders, the inhibitory effect of managerial ability on tunneling is not significant, which further reveals the functional boundary of subsidiary managerial ability. After the robustness test and endogenous treatment such as instrumental variable method, grouping regression and substitution variable, the conclusion is still valid. This paper complements and enriches the research of managerial ability in the field of corporate governance, breaks through the traditional "top-down" one-way governance viewpoint, verifies the feasibility of the "bottom-up" check and balance mechanism of subsidiaries, and provides new ideas and empirical evidence for solving the second kind of agency problems characterized by the opportunism of major shareholders.

    参考文献
    相似文献
    引证文献
引用本文

徐宁,张阳.子公司“自下而上”的制衡:实现路径、弱化因素与作用边界[J].重庆大学学报社会科学版,2022,28(3):52-66. DOI:10.11835/j. issn.1008-5831. jg.2022.04.005

复制
分享
文章指标
  • 点击次数:
  • 下载次数:
  • HTML阅读次数:
  • 引用次数:
历史
  • 收稿日期:
  • 最后修改日期:
  • 录用日期:
  • 在线发布日期: 2022-07-04
  • 出版日期: