数字经济的地方法治试验:理论阐释与实践路径
作者:
作者单位:

作者简介:

通讯作者:

中图分类号:

D927;F49;D921

基金项目:

国家社会科学基金重大项目"开放经济条件下我国虚拟经济安全运行法律保障研究"(14ZDB148);中央高校基本科研业务费资助项目"数字经济的地方法治试验及其限度研究(2021CDSKXYFX009)


The experiment of rule of law at the local level in digital economy: Theoretical explanation and practical path
Author:
Affiliation:

Fund Project:

  • 摘要
  • |
  • 图/表
  • |
  • 访问统计
  • |
  • 参考文献
  • |
  • 相似文献
  • |
  • 引证文献
  • |
  • 资源附件
  • |
  • 文章评论
    摘要:

    数字经济的异军突起,给作为治理体系和治理能力重要依托的法治秩序带来了挑战,也产生了全新的法治需求。面对新出现的"治理赤字",如何提供优质的"法治产品",构建有助于数字经济发展与治理的法治秩序,成为当务之急。但数字经济作为一种新生事物,高度依赖科技创新,处于不断创新、发展与变化之中,具有创新性、跨界性、虚拟性以及平台性等典型特征,由中央层面进行统一的法治供给面临诸多现实困难,也无法有效激活地方数字经济创新与发展的动力。为此,中央通过《国家数字经济创新发展试验区实施方案》,选择在部分地方进行数字经济创新发展与治理的试验,鼓励试验区加强体制机制创新和地方性法规探索。此背景下,数字经济领域的法治建设,除了由中央统一推动诸如《个人信息保护法》《数据安全法》等基础性法律制度的供给外,地方政府以法治试验的方式接入部分法治供给在理论层面何以可能,在实践层面是否具有现实基础、面临那些挑战以及如何克服,便成为不得不重视的问题。基于此,文章借助逻辑推理和实证分析方法,对数字经济领域地方法治试验的理论基础和实践路径进行了探索。研究发现,数字经济的地方法治试验,是一种有效回应数字经济法治需求的经验性治理方式。其理论逻辑在于以国家整体法治为最终归宿,以地方数字法治探索为切入口,在注重地方试错和经验积累的同时,将"自上而下"和"自下而上"的有机结合作为数字经济法治建设的路径选择,从中央和地方在数字经济发展与治理中各自所代表的利益及其所遭遇的现实困境出发,构建符合中国特色治理需求的数字法治格局。而宪法及其相关法律授予的地方法治创设权,中央对地方数字经济创新发展试验的授权与激励,以及部分省份"先行先试"的数字法治建设经验积累为该领域更大范围、更深层次的地方法治试验提供了现实可能。当然,数字经济的这种经验性法治路径也面临地方数字法治边界扩张、地方数据保护主义、地方数字治理方式单一等的挑战,需要以国家法制统一原则、全国统一市场目标,以及多元共治格局的构建等为限度,以此克服数字经济地方法治试验中的弊病,发挥其优势。

    Abstract:

    The sudden emergence of digital economy has brought challenges to the order of rule of law, which is an important support for the governance system and governance capacity, and also created a brand-new demand for the rule of law. Facing the new "governance deficit", how to provide high-quality "legal products" and build a legal order that is conducive to the development and governance of digital economy has become a top priority. However, digital economy, as a newly emerging thing, is highly dependent on scientific and technological innovation, and is in the process of continuous innovation, development and change, with typical characteristics such as being innovative, border-crossing, virtual and platform-based. The unified rule of law supply from the central level faces many practical difficulties, and it cannot effectively activate the driving force for innovation and development of local digital economy. To this end, the central government adopted the Implementation Plan of the National Digital Economy Innovation and Development Experimental Zone, selected some places to carry out pilot projects on digital economy innovation, development and governance, and encouraged the pilot zones to strengthen institutional innovation and explore local laws and regulations. Against this background, the development of the rule of law in the digital economy, in addition to the central government’s unified promotion of the supply of basic legal systems such as the Personal Information Protection Law and the Data Security Law, has become an issue that has to be paid attention to, such as how it is possible for local governments to access part of the rule of law supply in theory, whether it has a realistic foundation in practice, what challenges it faces and how to overcome them. Based on this, this paper explores the theoretical basis and practical path of the experiment of rule of law in the field of digital economy by means of logical reasoning and empirical analysis. Research finds that the experiment of rule of law at the local level in digital economy is an empirical governance method that effectively responds to the demand of rule of law in digital economy. The theoretical logic lies in taking the whole country’s rule of law as the ultimate destination, taking the exploration of local digital rule of law as the method, paying attention to local trial and error and experience accumulation, taking the organic combination of "top-down" and "bottom-up" as the path choice for the construction of digital economy rule of law, and starting from the interests represented by the central and local governments in the development and governance of digital economy and the realistic difficulties encountered, to construct the rule of law pattern meeting the governance needs with Chinese characteristics. However, the right to create local rule of law granted by the Constitution and its related laws, the authorization and encouragement of the central government to the pilots and trials in innovation-driven development of local digital economy, and the accumulation of digital rule of law development experience of the "pilot projects" in some provinces provide a realistic possibility for a wider and deeper local law-based pilot in this field. Of course, this empirical rule of law path of digital economy also faces challenges such as the expansion of local digital rule of law boundary, local data protectionism, and single local digital governance mode. It needs to be limited by the principle of national legal unity, the goal of national unified market, and the construction of pluralistic co-governance pattern, so as to overcome the disadvantages in the rule of law experiment at the local level of digital economy and give full play to its advantages.

    参考文献
    相似文献
    引证文献
引用本文

胡光志,苟学珍.数字经济的地方法治试验:理论阐释与实践路径[J].重庆大学学报社会科学版,2022,28(6):218-230. DOI:10.11835/j. issn.1008-5831. fx.2022.09.005

复制
分享
文章指标
  • 点击次数:
  • 下载次数:
  • HTML阅读次数:
  • 引用次数:
历史
  • 收稿日期:
  • 最后修改日期:
  • 录用日期:
  • 在线发布日期: 2023-02-03
  • 出版日期: